Posted on July 18th, 2015 by Adam-Troy Castro
So: conspiracy theory.
Take this with all the weight you take all conspiracy theories: i.e., practically none, given that it’s all supposition, and simply seems to fit one perspective on the facts. Don’t be fooled just because it happens to hinge on the doings of an actual, existing conspiracy; the conspiracy’s real, but their precise strategy and motives (as opposed to their stated strategy and motives) remain hypothetical to those of us outside it.
That doesn’t mean we can’t spitball.
So: Sad / Rabid Puppies.
The one I call {Moronic Massacre-Mocker} has announced that he’s voted NO AWARD in all categories, including the one where he has a nominee, in part, he says, to make some point about the Hugos being invalid.
John Scalzi has recently tweeted to the effect that this claim has now becoming fashionable among the Puppies. I don’t know. {MMM} is the only one I’ve seen say it, but there may be more.
Let us assume, the operative word being “assume” and the open admission being that it is as trustworthy as any assumption, that Scalzi’s claim is accurate and that a number of the conspirators have indeed voted “NO AWARD” even for their own stories on a ballot they previously did their level best to capture whole.
Given that they have previously said that a No Award in any category is proof that the Hugos have been hijacked by a conspiracy of SJWS and that writers of good-old-fashioned traditional science fiction without imbedded leftist messages cannot get a break, given that they’ve tried so hard to get to this point, why would they do this now? Why would they fly so close to the sun, on borrowed wings, before pulling the feathers out and plunging back to the earth, like Icarus?
This is my theory.
It may not be at all accurate. Again, I do not present this as verifiable fact. But this is what I think and this is what I hope.
They’ve done the math.
They know how many Supporting Memberships Sasquan has picked up since this mess began. And while we have been stuck saying we don’t know how many of those supporting memberships are voters they or their allies have subsidized – quite a few, possibly, given how their allies include the Breitbart organization – and how many have been fans outraged by their tactics who have bought supporting memberships just to vote them down in every possible category, they DO know how many memberships they’ve bought; they do know how many memberships they’ve paid for, and they do know that after all their rants and fulminations and promises to smash the Hugos, they know that the numbers suggest that backlash numerically superior. They have begun to realize that they’re in for a drubbing of historical proportions. NO AWARD in any category dominated by their candidates. Hugos going to the stories and candidates they had nothing to do with.
And faced with this fear (it cannot be a certainty), they have taken the bold pre-emptive public relations step of repositioning that possible result as a victory.
So {Moronic Massacre-Mocker} has said that he’s voting NO AWARD in every category, even ahead of his own story, thus altering the presumed goal of all this unpleasantness from making sure Hugo nominations and Hugo trophies only go to real nuts-and-bolts science fiction for the only science fiction readers who count, to sabotaging the awards completely, making sure nobody gets any, and in that way proving that scorched Earth was always the only option.
This is, of course, if Scalzi is right and anybody other than {Moronic Massacre-Mocker} has said it.
So far I’ve only seen the rant from {Moronic Massacre-Mocker}, who is being given a time-out from Facebook for hate speech.
But if we permit consideration of the possibility that it has become a meme, it represents a serious shift in strategy and a complete rebranding of the desired goal.
We wanted the ship to sink. We always wanted to make a point about icebergs.
We wanted our village to be sacked. It proves our moral superiority to the huns.
Yes, I just slammed myself in the balls with a sledgehammer. I meant to do that.
Maybe they know how many supporting memberships they paid for and how many they did not. Maybe they’ve convened in panic and discussed how to still pull a nominal victory out of all this. Maybe they’ve said, “We have to sell the premise that if we go down in flames, it’s what we always intended.”
Maybe they’re terrified.
This is just a conspiracy theory, mind you. It might or might not have any validity. But the shift from, “VOTING NO AWARD IS A TERRIBLE THING TO DO!” to “WE ARE NOW VOTING NO AWARD EVEN IN OUR OWN CATEGORIES!” does give me pause….
Tags: Hugos, John Scalzi, Moronic Massacre-Mocker, sad puppies, Science Fiction | Category Books, Commentary, Science Fiction, Writing