A Reminder That Our Imaginary Pals Are Mostly Intolerable People
Posted on September 29th, 2015 by Adam-Troy CastroFirst Published on Facebook 29 September 2014.
A key misunderstanding people have about their relationship with fiction is the belief that their favorite characters are people they would like to hang around with.
In a sense, this is what they’re doing when they read a story or watch a TV show; they are hanging out with people, more intimately than they hang out with real human beings. They not only see the most intimate moments of these people; in many cases they’re privy to their actual thoughts. That’s where the love, and the empathy, we have for them comes from.
But then comes the thought that they would like to hang out with these people. Which is where “Mary Sue” fiction comes from.
And I will make a point of saying that I am not immune to this myself. Without ever losing track of reality, I have daydreamed at idle moments of transporting myself onto the deck of the ENTERPRISE, or hanging out with Hawkeye and B.J in the Swamp, or helping Sherlock Holmes on a case, or fighting alongside the Musketeers, or helping out Batman, or…you know. It goes on.
This is all based on the illusion that we would *actually* like to know these people, but the sad fact is that much of what makes many fictional characters compelling is incompatible with actually wanting to know them. Guys think they would like to hang out with Conan. But to do so they first re-invent themselves as a guy who *can* hang out with Conan. If they’re not that guy, Conan is a lumbering jerk. Girls (and yes, some gay guys) want to hang out with Conan for another reason, and that might make a memorable if exhausting evening, but honestly, he’s not relationship material. He’s a pig. Sherlock Holmes? Going back to Conan Doyle, he’s a remote and impossible man, difficult to know; and if you do manage to forge a relationship with him, he will insult you mercilessly. The Three Musketeers? Fun guys to drink with, but god forbid you spill ale on one. He’ll pull a sword and threaten you at the most minor offense.
Dreams about being on the ENTERPRISE? In real life, I would be creeped out by Data and downright contemptuous of Worf. I would find Kirk and Spock unknowable and harbor secret contempt for McCoy’s bigotry.
In many cases, even if the character is an uncomplicated nice guy, you likely enjoy being a spectator much more than you would enjoy hanging out on a regular basis. I have nothing whatsoever in common with, to name one, Rocky Balboa. As tentative friends, we would drift apart in an afternoon. Ditto with David Copperfield. I would have nothing to talk about with Tom Joad or Huckleberry Finn. I would never get anything but affable politeness from Barney Miller. I would feel sorry for Jean Valjean and might even be moved to help him but would not find him the life of the party. I would run like hell from Seinfeld and his friends, and I would dislike just about everybody I met at Dick Louden’s Bed and Breakfast in Vermont. I would feel nothing for revulsion for Ignatius J. Reilly. And I should thank God daily I am not a neighbor of Peter Parker, that evasive, secretive, self-pitying, superficially charming but flaky and unreliable liar, purveyor of bizarre excuses for ditching you – and that’s before I get to the risk of being collateral damage when some super-villain attacks.
I created Andrea Cort to be unhappy, bitter, prickly, fragile, needy and brilliant. It’s fair to say that I love her, absolutely love her. So do many of the people who read her adventures. In real life, I would write her off fairly quickly, and run like hell.
We’ve all fallen in uncomplicated love with some male or female character glimpsed in fiction, thinking that they would be perfect for us if only they were real. I could fill a small book with fictional ladies I found adorable, who as a single man I would take out to dinner in a heartbeat – but that, first, assumes that as written they would have anything to do with me, either in the short or long term. (Farewell, Mary Richards; farewell, Pam from THE OFFICE.) These fantasy relationships are, even in the case of the most fully realized characters, constructed out of our own heads. That characters have not made overtures to us. We have built the bridges out of our own brain-stuff. If the characters did actually possess the depth of real human beings, we would no doubt discover things about them that we didn’t like. In many cases, that we didn’t like *a lot.” Ladies: you honestly don’t want to know Heathcliff.
We only think we want our fictional characters to be people we’d like to know.
In almost all cases, they’re more properly people we want to learn about.


